You catch your reflection in the office bathroom or your car’s rearview mirror, only to find your perfectly applied cat eye has migrated to your under eye area or vanished entirely. For years, makeup lovers have faced a binary choice, a traditional wooden pencil that offers precision but fades fast, or a liquid liner that lasts all day but requires a surgeon’s steady hand.
The Milk Makeup Infinity Long Wear Eyeliner. This isn’t just another pencil, it is a 3 in 1 power tool for your eyes. By combining the blendability of a kohl, the precision of a sharpened tip, and the longevity of a tattoo liner, Milk Makeup claims to have cracked the code on clean, waterproof performance.
Shipping is free for Prime Members or on orders over $35; otherwise, it adds $6.99.
Online Deal at Amazon
Milk Makeup Infinity Long Wear Eyeliner
What to buy
Twist Up, Sharpen, & Smudge
Most eyeliners are one trick ponies. You buy the pencil, then a sharpener, then a smudge brush. The genius of the Milk Makeup Infinity Eyeliner lies in its hardware. It is designed for the modern, busy consumer who applies makeup on the go whether that’s in the back of an Uber or a gym locker room.
The Mechanics of a Twist Up Eyeliner
At first glance, it looks like a standard retractable pencil, twist the body, and the product rises. This eliminates the messy shavings of wooden pencils. However, retractable pencils often suffer from one major flaw, once the tip blunts, you are stuck with a thick, imprecise line.
A Built In Sharpener
Many users go through their entire pencil without realizing this feature exists. Tucked discreetly into the bottom cap is a detachable sharpener.
This is a game changer for tightlining. By gently twisting the tip into this hidden module, you regain a needle fine point in seconds. It allows you to switch from a thick, messy grunge look to a razor sharp wing without searching for a separate tool.
The Soft Blender Tip
On the opposite end, you’ll find an angled smudge tip. Unlike scratchy sponge tips from the early 2000s, this blender is firm yet soft. It drags the pigment out smoothly, allowing you to create a shadow liner effect without needing a separate makeup brush.
Is It Really Waterproof
12 hour wear is a specific metric that requires validation, the primary pain point for most users is oily eyelids, where sebum breaks down makeup faster than water does.
The magic of this formula is its play time. Upon application, the liner is emollient, giving you roughly 30 to 60 seconds to smudge or correct mistakes.
Once that minute is up, the volatile oils evaporate, and the pigments lock onto the skin. In our testing, once this product sets, it becomes virtually transfer proof. You can rub your eye, get caught in the rain, or sweat through a spin class, and the line remains crisp.
Safe for the Waterline
The waterline is the hardest place for makeup to survive. Because the Infinity Eyeliner is ophthalmologist tested, it is safe for this sensitive area. The waterproof formula clings to the wet mucosa better than traditional waxes, making it a top contender for the fully rimmed eye look.
The Science of Clean Performance
For a long time, waterproof meant harsh chemicals. Traditional liners often relied on heavy silicones or animal derived ingredients like beeswax. Milk Makeup, staying true to its ethos, formulated this product to be 100% Vegan and Cruelty Free.
- Avocado Oil: Rich in fatty acids, this is the secret behind the tug free application. It allows the pencil to skip over textured skin without dragging.
- Ceramides: These lipids help restore the skin barrier. Since the eye area has the thinnest skin on the body, ceramides prevent the liner from drying out and flaking.
- Aloe Vera Extract: Known for its soothing properties, aloe ensures comfortable wear a massive plus for contact lens wearers.
Online Deal at Amazon
Milk Makeup Infinity Long Wear Eyeliner
What to buy
This is the ultimate eyeliner for the practical perfectionist. If you need makeup that looks the same at 7:00 PM as it did at 7:00 AM, this is your holy grail. It effectively bridges the gap between clean beauty and high performance durability.
Want more ways to stay up to date with Offers Earth Deals? Follow Offers Earth on Telegram.

As a savvy shopper, my passion is finding the best deals and sharing them with you. I spend my time scouring Amazon, eBay, Walmart, and other online stores to unearth amazing deals, valuable coupons, and products that are actually worth your money. Follow along for my latest finds.
